NOWPayments, CoinGate and BTCPay vs card-to-crypto gateways

NOWPayments, CoinGate and BTCPay Server excel when buyers already hold crypto (0%-1%). When shoppers only have cards, a card-to-crypto gateway fills the gap.

On this page

Merchants looking to accept cards and get paid in crypto often start by installing NOWPayments, CoinGate or BTCPay Server — and quickly discover a mismatch. Those three tools are built primarily for shoppers who already hold cryptocurrency in their own wallet. Most everyday shoppers do not: they arrive at checkout with a Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay or Google Pay.

If your customers already pay in Bitcoin, Litecoin or USDT, a crypto-only gateway is dramatically cheaper than any card checkout (0% to 1% total). If most of your buyers want to pay by card while you settle in USDC, you need a card-to-crypto gateway such as Caravel Pay — or both running side by side.

Disclosure. We make Caravel Pay, a card-to-crypto gateway. Facts about NOWPayments, CoinGate and BTCPay Server come from their public documentation and WordPress.org listings, checked on 21 November 2026 and linked in Sources. Caravel Pay is not affiliated with any of them, and all trademarks belong to their owners.

Two different jobs at checkout#

  • Crypto-to-crypto gateways (NOWPayments, CoinGate, BTCPay Server): the buyer opens their own crypto wallet and sends BTC, ETH, USDT or another coin. There is no card network, so fees are tiny (0% to 1%) and checkout is instant for crypto-native buyers. The catch is audience size: shoppers without a funded crypto wallet abandon the cart.
  • Card-to-crypto gateways (Caravel Pay and similar tools): the buyer pays with an ordinary Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay or Google Pay on a hosted page. An independent card on-ramp provider takes the card payment, sells USDC as part of checkout, and the gateway forwards USDC straight to your Polygon wallet. You reach normal card-paying shoppers without applying for a traditional merchant account, at the cost of the card provider's fee plus the gateway fee.

Side by side#

ToolPrimary buyer payment methodPublished feePayout to youSetup & seller checksWordPress.org WooCommerce plugin
NOWPayments300+ cryptocurrencies from buyer's wallet (fiat/card via third-party partners such as Guardarian)0.4%–0.5% same-coin, 1% with conversion; partner fees apply on fiatCrypto to your wallet (or fiat via partners)Account + API key; fiat features require partner onboarding/KYC3,000+ active installs; v1.4.1 (updated 25 Aug 2026)
CoinGateCryptocurrencies from buyer's wallet1% flat on crypto; bank payout fees (e.g. €0.50 + 0.5%–1.5%)Crypto or bank payouts (EUR, USD, GBP)Regulated EU business account with KYB verification400+ active installs; v2.3.0 (updated 8 Sep 2025)
BTCPay ServerBitcoin & Lightning (plus altcoin plugins) from buyer's wallet0% platform fee (you pay VPS/hosting, typically $3–$30+/mo)100% self-custody straight to your walletSelf-hosted server or managed host; no third-party account1,000+ active installs; v2.8.9 (updated 15 Nov 2026)
Caravel PayCard, Apple Pay, Google Pay (plus direct USDC, USDC.e and POL on Polygon)2% Caravel fee on the order total, plus the card provider's own fee (~3% typical of recent card orders; varies)USDC on Polygon straight to your wallet (payout gas included)No account, no monthly fee, no KYC for your business; paste a walletFewer than 10 active installs; v1.2.8 (updated 19 Nov 2026)

The real cost difference on a $100 order#

Be honest about the maths before you pick:

  • Buyer already has crypto (BTCPay / NOWPayments / CoinGate): on a $100 order you keep $99.00 to $100.00 before tiny network fees. No card-to-crypto checkout can beat 0%–1% when the customer already holds coins.
  • Buyer only has a Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay or Google Pay (Caravel Pay): your buyer pays $100. Most card providers keep their fee and spread out of that amount — about 3% is typical of recent card orders through Caravel Pay (some arrive in full; a few routes keep up to about 8–10%). On a $100 order where $97.00 arrives as USDC, the 2% Caravel fee ($2.00) leaves 95.00 USDC in your wallet.

You are not paying ~5% total instead of 0.5% for the same buyer. You are paying the card-rail cost to convert shoppers who would otherwise leave your checkout because they do not own crypto.

Chargebacks, KYC and custody#

  • Crypto-only (BTCPay, NOWPayments, CoinGate): crypto payments are final on-chain with no card chargebacks. CoinGate requires full EU KYB verification because it settles to bank accounts; BTCPay requires none because you run your own software.
  • Caravel Pay (card-to-USDC): payouts are final on-chain transfers in USDC on Polygon, and we never hold a balance for you. A card dispute stays between the buyer, their bank and the independent card provider: the provider does not know who you are and cannot contact you about a dispute. Caravel Pay can pause a merchant we suspect of fraud. On the buyer side, the card provider may ask a first-time buyer to verify their identity.

When NOWPayments, CoinGate or BTCPay is the right answer#

  • Most of your buyers already hold Bitcoin, USDT or other crypto. Use BTCPay Server (0% fee, full self-custody) or NOWPayments (0.5%–1%, 300+ coins) — paying card on-ramp fees makes no sense for crypto-native buyers.
  • You want EUR, USD or GBP deposited straight into a business bank account and can pass EU business verification: CoinGate is built for that. Caravel Pay has no bank payout.
  • You want a multi-year track record and thousands of active stores. NOWPayments (3,000+ WooCommerce installs since 2022) and BTCPay (1,000+ installs) are mature tools; Caravel Pay launched in November 2026.

When Caravel Pay fits — or why many stores run both#

The best setup for many online stores is not either/or. Keep BTCPay Server or NOWPayments active as your "Pay with Crypto" option so crypto-holding buyers pay 0%–1% fees across dozens of coins, and place Caravel Pay right next to it as your "Pay by Card / Apple Pay / Google Pay" option for everyone else.

That way, crypto buyers never touch a card on-ramp, card buyers do not bounce off a wallet QR code, and both options settle straight to wallets you control with no traditional merchant account or rolling reserve. To see how Caravel Pay compares against other card-to-crypto WooCommerce plugins, read card-to-crypto WooCommerce plugins compared.

Sources#

Frequently asked questions#

Can customers pay with a credit card on NOWPayments or BTCPay Server?#

BTCPay Server does not process credit cards natively; it is built for direct Bitcoin, Lightning and crypto wallet payments. NOWPayments focuses on 300+ cryptocurrencies and supports fiat/card flows only through third-party partners with separate partner terms and fees. A card-to-crypto gateway like Caravel Pay is built specifically for card, Apple Pay and Google Pay buyers who do not hold crypto.

Should I replace NOWPayments or BTCPay with Caravel Pay?#

Usually no — run them side by side. Keep BTCPay or NOWPayments for customers who already hold crypto (0%–1% fees), and add Caravel Pay next to it for buyers paying with Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay or Google Pay.

Why does a card-to-crypto payment cost more than a direct crypto payment?#

Because an independent card provider has to process the buyer's card payment and convert it to USDC, keeping its own fee (about 3% is typical of recent card orders through Caravel Pay) before the 2% Caravel fee comes off. When a buyer pays directly in USDC on Polygon through Caravel Pay, there is no card provider fee — only the 2% Caravel fee.