# NOWPayments, CoinGate and BTCPay vs card-to-crypto gateways

Source: https://caravelpay.app/guides/nowpayments-vs-card-to-crypto/ · Caravel Pay guides · By the Caravel Pay team · Published 2026-11-21

NOWPayments, CoinGate and BTCPay Server excel when buyers already hold crypto (0%-1%). When shoppers only have cards, a card-to-crypto gateway fills the gap.

Merchants looking to accept cards and get paid in crypto often start by installing **NOWPayments**, **CoinGate** or **BTCPay Server** — and quickly discover a mismatch. Those three tools are built primarily for shoppers who **already hold cryptocurrency in their own wallet**. Most everyday shoppers do not: they arrive at checkout with a Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay or Google Pay.

If your customers already pay in Bitcoin, Litecoin or USDT, a crypto-only gateway is dramatically cheaper than any card checkout (0% to 1% total). If most of your buyers want to pay by card while you settle in USDC, you need a **card-to-crypto gateway** such as Caravel Pay — or both running side by side.

> **Disclosure.** We make Caravel Pay, a card-to-crypto gateway. Facts about NOWPayments, CoinGate and BTCPay Server come from their public documentation and WordPress.org listings, checked on 21 November 2026 and linked in [Sources](https://caravelpay.app/guides/nowpayments-vs-card-to-crypto/#sources). Caravel Pay is not affiliated with any of them, and all trademarks belong to their owners.

## Two different jobs at checkout

- **Crypto-to-crypto gateways (NOWPayments, CoinGate, BTCPay Server):** the buyer opens their own crypto wallet and sends BTC, ETH, USDT or another coin. There is no card network, so fees are tiny (0% to 1%) and checkout is instant for crypto-native buyers. The catch is audience size: shoppers without a funded crypto wallet abandon the cart.
- **Card-to-crypto gateways (Caravel Pay and similar tools):** the buyer pays with an ordinary Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay or Google Pay on a hosted page. An independent card on-ramp provider takes the card payment, sells USDC as part of checkout, and the gateway forwards USDC straight to your Polygon wallet. You reach normal card-paying shoppers without applying for a traditional merchant account, at the cost of the card provider's fee plus the gateway fee.

## Side by side

| Tool | Primary buyer payment method | Published fee | Payout to you | Setup & seller checks | WordPress.org WooCommerce plugin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NOWPayments | 300+ cryptocurrencies from buyer's wallet (fiat/card via third-party partners such as Guardarian) | 0.4%–0.5% same-coin, 1% with conversion; partner fees apply on fiat | Crypto to your wallet (or fiat via partners) | Account + API key; fiat features require partner onboarding/KYC | 3,000+ active installs; v1.4.1 (updated 25 Aug 2026) |
| CoinGate | Cryptocurrencies from buyer's wallet | 1% flat on crypto; bank payout fees (e.g. €0.50 + 0.5%–1.5%) | Crypto or bank payouts (EUR, USD, GBP) | Regulated EU business account with KYB verification | 400+ active installs; v2.3.0 (updated 8 Sep 2025) |
| BTCPay Server | Bitcoin & Lightning (plus altcoin plugins) from buyer's wallet | 0% platform fee (you pay VPS/hosting, typically $3–$30+/mo) | 100% self-custody straight to your wallet | Self-hosted server or managed host; no third-party account | 1,000+ active installs; v2.8.9 (updated 15 Nov 2026) |
| **Caravel Pay** | **Card, Apple Pay, Google Pay** (plus direct USDC, USDC.e and POL on Polygon) | **2% Caravel fee** on the order total, plus the card provider's own fee (~3% typical of recent card orders; varies) | USDC on Polygon straight to your wallet (payout gas included) | No account, no monthly fee, no KYC for your business; paste a wallet | Fewer than 10 active installs; v1.2.8 (updated 19 Nov 2026) |

## The real cost difference on a $100 order

Be honest about the maths before you pick:

- **Buyer already has crypto (BTCPay / NOWPayments / CoinGate):** on a $100 order you keep **$99.00 to $100.00** before tiny network fees. No card-to-crypto checkout can beat 0%–1% when the customer already holds coins.
- **Buyer only has a Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay or Google Pay (Caravel Pay):** your buyer pays $100. Most card providers keep their fee and spread out of that amount — about 3% is typical of recent card orders through Caravel Pay (some arrive in full; a few routes keep up to about 8–10%). On a $100 order where $97.00 arrives as USDC, the 2% Caravel fee ($2.00) leaves **95.00 USDC** in your wallet.

You are not paying ~5% total instead of 0.5% for the same buyer. You are paying the card-rail cost to convert shoppers who would otherwise leave your checkout because they do not own crypto.

## Chargebacks, KYC and custody

- **Crypto-only (BTCPay, NOWPayments, CoinGate):** crypto payments are final on-chain with no card chargebacks. CoinGate requires full EU KYB verification because it settles to bank accounts; BTCPay requires none because you run your own software.
- **Caravel Pay (card-to-USDC):** payouts are final on-chain transfers in USDC on Polygon, and we never hold a balance for you. A card dispute stays between the buyer, their bank and the independent card provider: the provider does not know who you are and cannot contact you about a dispute. Caravel Pay can pause a merchant we suspect of fraud. On the buyer side, the card provider may ask a first-time buyer to verify their identity.

## When NOWPayments, CoinGate or BTCPay is the right answer

- **Most of your buyers already hold Bitcoin, USDT or other crypto.** Use BTCPay Server (0% fee, full self-custody) or NOWPayments (0.5%–1%, 300+ coins) — paying card on-ramp fees makes no sense for crypto-native buyers.
- **You want EUR, USD or GBP deposited straight into a business bank account** and can pass EU business verification: CoinGate is built for that. Caravel Pay has no bank payout.
- **You want a multi-year track record and thousands of active stores.** NOWPayments (3,000+ WooCommerce installs since 2022) and BTCPay (1,000+ installs) are mature tools; Caravel Pay launched in November 2026.

## When Caravel Pay fits — or why many stores run both

The best setup for many online stores is not either/or. Keep **BTCPay Server** or **NOWPayments** active as your "Pay with Crypto" option so crypto-holding buyers pay 0%–1% fees across dozens of coins, and place **Caravel Pay** right next to it as your "Pay by Card / Apple Pay / Google Pay" option for everyone else.

That way, crypto buyers never touch a card on-ramp, card buyers do not bounce off a wallet QR code, and both options settle straight to wallets you control with no traditional merchant account or rolling reserve. To see how Caravel Pay compares against other card-to-crypto WooCommerce plugins, read [card-to-crypto WooCommerce plugins compared](https://caravelpay.app/guides/card-to-crypto-woocommerce-plugins-compared/).

## Sources

- [NOWPayments for WooCommerce on WordPress.org](https://wordpress.org/plugins/nowpayments-for-woocommerce/) and [nowpayments.io](https://nowpayments.io/) (checked 21 November 2026)
- [CoinGate for WooCommerce on WordPress.org](https://wordpress.org/plugins/coingate-for-woocommerce/) and [coingate.com](https://coingate.com/) (checked 21 November 2026)
- [BTCPay Server for WooCommerce on WordPress.org](https://wordpress.org/plugins/btcpay-greenfield-for-woocommerce/) and [btcpayserver.org](https://btcpayserver.org/) (checked 21 November 2026)
- [Caravel Pay on WordPress.org](https://wordpress.org/plugins/caravel-pay/) and [Caravel Pay pricing](https://caravelpay.app/pricing/)

## Frequently asked questions

### Can customers pay with a credit card on NOWPayments or BTCPay Server?

BTCPay Server does not process credit cards natively; it is built for direct Bitcoin, Lightning and crypto wallet payments. NOWPayments focuses on 300+ cryptocurrencies and supports fiat/card flows only through third-party partners with separate partner terms and fees. A card-to-crypto gateway like Caravel Pay is built specifically for card, Apple Pay and Google Pay buyers who do not hold crypto.

### Should I replace NOWPayments or BTCPay with Caravel Pay?

Usually no — run them side by side. Keep BTCPay or NOWPayments for customers who already hold crypto (0%–1% fees), and add Caravel Pay next to it for buyers paying with Visa, Mastercard, Apple Pay or Google Pay.

### Why does a card-to-crypto payment cost more than a direct crypto payment?

Because an independent card provider has to process the buyer's card payment and convert it to USDC, keeping its own fee (about 3% is typical of recent card orders through Caravel Pay) before the 2% Caravel fee comes off. When a buyer pays directly in USDC on Polygon through Caravel Pay, there is no card provider fee — only the 2% Caravel fee.
